cloud9342111.lol

How to Set Up a Reliable CD Offline Pipeline

Written by

admin

in

How to Set Up a Reliable CD Offline PipelineContinuous Delivery (CD) pipelines are typically designed around always-on networks, cloud services, and automated artifact stores. But there are many real-world situations where a pipeline must operate offline or with limited connectivity: air-gapped environments, classified or regulated systems, remote sites with intermittent internet, or scenarios where data exfiltration must be prevented. This guide walks through planning, designing, implementing, and maintaining a reliable CD offline pipeline — from requirements and constraints to concrete tools, workflows, and best practices.

1. Understand requirements and constraints

Before designing the pipeline, document the environment and constraints:

  • Security and compliance: Are you operating in an air-gapped environment? What regulatory controls (e.g., FIPS, DISA STIGs) apply?
  • Connectivity model: Fully offline (no external network), periodically connected (scheduled sync windows), or limited outbound-only?
  • Artifact sources: Where do builds and third-party dependencies originate? How will they be transported?
  • Deployment targets: Servers, embedded devices, OT equipment, containers, or VMs? What OSes and package formats are used?
  • Change/approval workflow: Is automated promotion allowed, or must human approvals occur at each stage?
  • Recovery and audit: How will you prove what was deployed and restore to a prior state if needed?

Record these as constraints that will drive architecture decisions (e.g., physically transferring artifacts vs. using a one-way data diode).

2. Design principles for offline CD

Adopt principles that make the offline pipeline robust:

  • Minimize trust surface: use signed artifacts and verified provenance so artifacts can be validated without contacting external services.
  • Deterministic builds: prefer reproducible builds to ensure artifacts built externally match what will be deployed offline.
  • Immutable artifacts: deploy versioned, immutable artifacts (container images, signed packages) rather than ad-hoc builds on the target.
  • Explicit sync procedure: define how and when artifacts, dependencies, and metadata will be transported into the offline zone.
  • Auditability and provenance: maintain cryptographic signatures, SBOMs (software bill of materials), and deployment logs.
  • Graceful rollback: store previous artifact versions and clear rollback steps.
  • Least privilege and segmentation: limit who can transfer media into the offline environment and segregate staging from production.

3. Core components of an offline CD pipeline

Typical components — adapted for offline constraints — include:

  • Build system (CI): the place artifacts are produced (often on a connected network).
  • Artifact repository: stores build outputs (container registry, package repo, or file server).
  • Transport mechanism: secure transfer of artifacts into the offline environment (portable encrypted media, data diode, or scheduled sync via a proxy).
  • Verification tools: signature verification (GPG, Sigstore/fulcio/tuf), SBOMs, and checksums.
  • Deployment automation: configuration management or orchestration within the offline network (Ansible, Salt, Nomad, Kubernetes with an internal registry).
  • Observability and logging: local monitoring and log aggregation for the offline environment.
  • Access and approval workflow: ticketing, approval UI, or physical sign-off processes.

4. Choosing tools and formats

Select tools that support offline usage and cryptographic verification.

  • Artifact formats: container images (OCI), signed tarballs, OS packages (.deb/.rpm), or firmware/OTA bundles. Prefer immutable, versioned formats.
  • Registries/repositories: host an internal Docker registry (Harbor, Docker Distribution), APT/YUM repos, or an artifact manager like Nexus/Artifactory that can run offline.
  • Signing & provenance: use Sigstore (rekor/fulcio/cosign) if network-limited components are available; otherwise GPG signatures and timestamped attestations. Generate SBOMs (CycloneDX or SPDX).
  • Build systems: Jenkins, GitHub Actions (self-hosted), GitLab CI (self-hosted), or Tekton — runable in an on-prem CI server. Ensure builds are reproducible.
  • Deployment automation: Ansible (agentless), Salt, or a Kubernetes cluster using an internal image registry and ArgoCD operated fully inside the air-gapped network. ArgoCD can work with a private repo inside the environment.
  • Verification frameworks: The Update Framework (TUF) for secure repository sync, or in-house checksum+GPG verification scripts. TUF is designed for untrusted networks and can help secure offline syncing.

5. Typical offline CD workflows

Below are sample workflows for common connectivity models.

Workflow A — Periodic secure sync (most common)

  1. Build artifacts on the connected CI/CD server; sign artifacts and produce SBOMs.
  2. Push artifacts to a staging artifact repository (connected).
  3. Create a curated transfer bundle: select versions, include signatures, SBOMs, metadata, and a manifest.
  4. Export bundle to encrypted portable media (e.g., LUKS-encrypted drive) or to an internal transfer server that sits on a one-way network interface.
  5. Physically transport media to the offline environment; the receiving operator checks signatures and manifest, then imports into the internal artifact repository.
  6. Trigger deployment via local orchestration; run verification and smoke tests.
  7. Log results locally and produce signed deployment receipts for audit.

Workflow B — One-way sync (data diode)

  1. Same as above for build and bundle creation.
  2. Use a one-way replication setup or synchronization server that pushes data through a data diode into the offline repo.
  3. The offline side verifies signatures and automatically promotes artifacts to staging/production based on preconfigured rules.

Workflow C — Fully air-gapped local build

  1. Deliver source, build scripts, and approved dependencies via transfer bundle.
  2. Build inside the air-gapped environment on an internal CI runner to maximize security.
  3. Sign artifacts locally using internal keys and store artifacts in local repo.
  4. Deploy using internal orchestration.

6. Secure transfer and artifact validation

  • Use cryptographic signatures: every artifact should be signed. Store and distribute public verification keys securely inside the offline zone. Do not rely on transport secrecy alone.
  • SBOMs: include SBOMs for dependencies and transitive packages to meet compliance and vulnerability scanning requirements.
  • Checksums & manifests: checksums, hashes (SHA-256), and a signed manifest listing all artifacts help ensure integrity.
  • Timestamps and notarization: if possible, use an authoritative timestamp or re-sign artifacts inside the offline environment after verification.
  • Use secure, tamper-evident media: sealed, encrypted drives and strict chain-of-custody procedures for physical transport.

7. Approval, audit, and compliance

  • Implement a formal approval pipeline: maintain signed approval artifacts (emails, tickets, or signed manifests).
  • Record every transfer: who moved media, when, and chain-of-custody details. Keep signed receipts.
  • Keep detailed deployment logs and signed deployment metadata (who triggered, what artifact versions, checksums).
  • Retain old artifacts and manifests for rollback and investigation. Store in an immutable or write-once archive if possible.

8. Testing, verification, and rollback

  • Pre-deployment testing: run unit, integration, and system tests before export. For higher assurance, run critical tests both before export and after import in the offline zone.
  • Post-deployment smoke tests: automated sanity checks that run immediately after deployment; report results to local logs and sign the results.
  • Rollback plan: keep previous artifact versions in the offline repo and document rollback commands and procedures. Automate rollback where safe.
  • Disaster recovery: maintain an offline backup strategy for artifacts and configurations, and test restoration periodically.

9. Operational practices and hardening

  • Harden all hosts: follow system hardening guides and limit network interfaces.
  • Key management: store signing keys in a hardware security module (HSM) or secure vault; minimize access and rotate keys per policy. If keys must be used in the offline zone, use an HSM or procedural protections.
  • Patch management: maintain a secure method to bring security updates into the offline environment — treat it like a controlled supply chain operation.
  • Logging and monitoring: run local SIEM or logging stacks and ensure logs are preserved per retention policies.
  • Least privilege: restrict who can import artifacts, promote to production, or trigger deployments.

10. Example: setting up an air-gapped container-based CD pipeline (concise steps)

  1. Self-hosted CI (Jenkins/GitLab Runner) builds OCI images; images are signed with cosign and an SBOM is generated (CycloneDX).
  2. Push images into a connected artifact registry. Create a transfer bundle containing images (tarred), cosign signatures, SBOMs, and a signed manifest.
  3. Export bundle to an encrypted SSD following chain-of-custody procedures.
  4. Transport to the air-gapped datacenter. Import images into an internal Harbor or Docker Distribution registry. Verify cosign signatures and SBOMs.
  5. Use ArgoCD inside the air-gapped Kubernetes cluster to pull images from the internal registry and deploy. ArgoCD reads manifests stored in an internal Git server or a local artifact store.
  6. Run automated smoke tests, log results, and store signed deployment receipts.

11. Common pitfalls and mitigations

  • Pitfall: relying on unsigned artifacts — leads to tampering risk. Mitigation: enforce mandatory signature verification.
  • Pitfall: incomplete dependency transfer — missing transitive packages break builds. Mitigation: generate complete SBOMs and dependency bundles.
  • Pitfall: weak chain-of-custody for physical media. Mitigation: strict procedures, tamper-evident seals, and logging.
  • Pitfall: keys compromised or poorly stored. Mitigation: use HSMs, hardware tokens, and strict access control.
  • Pitfall: manual steps cause delays and errors. Mitigation: automate import/verification tasks inside the offline environment as much as policy allows.

12. Measuring reliability and success

Track metrics to prove pipeline reliability:

  • Deployment success rate and mean time to recovery (MTTR).
  • Time from artifact creation to deployment in offline environment (lead time).
  • Number of integrity verification failures (signatures/checksums).
  • Frequency of rollback events and root causes.
  • Audit completeness: percent of deployments with complete signed metadata and SBOMs.

13. Conclusion

A reliable CD offline pipeline combines disciplined design, cryptographic verification, reproducible artifacts, carefully documented transfer procedures, and automation where possible. The goal is to create a supply chain that preserves integrity, supports audits, and enables predictable deployments even without continuous connectivity. Start small: prove the sync-and-verify pattern with a simple app, then expand toolchains and automation as processes stabilize.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More posts